Thirty years ago, a young baker vanished?and one forgotten recipe card may finally reveal what happened to her.

Every Thursday in Pecan Hollow, Georgia, Dottie, Nora, Celia, and Mae gather for supper, gossip, and conversation. But when Celia discovers Lila Hart's handwritten blackberry buttermilk pie recipe tucked inside a donated cookbook, the Cold Case Supper Club has a mystery to solve.

On the back is a cryptic note about an 8:30 meeting at the springhouse?and receipts no one ever investigated.

Soon, the four amateur sleuths are digging into old festival records, suspicious repair invoices, missing flood-relief money, and a town secret buried for three decades. When the sheriff finally opens the long-sealed springhouse, the truth about Lila's disappearance comes dangerously close to home.

The Missing Piece of Pie is a warm Southern cozy mystery filled with friendship, small-town secrets, cold-case clues, and plenty of pie.